Statute:

Sustaining or dismissing petition

ยง 1051. Sustaining or dismissing petition. (a) If facts sufficient to
sustain the petition are established in accord with part four of this
article, or if all parties and the attorney for the child consent, the
court shall, subject to the provisions of subdivision (c) of this
section, enter an order finding that the child is an abused child or a
neglected child and shall state the grounds for the finding.

(b) If the proof does not conform to the specific allegations of the
petition, the court may amend the allegations to conform to the proof;
provided, however, that in such case the respondent shall be given
reasonable time to prepare to answer the amended allegations.

(c) If facts sufficient to sustain the petition under this article are
not established, or if, in a case of alleged neglect, the court
concludes that its aid is not required on the record before it, the
court shall dismiss the petition and shall state on the record the
grounds for the dismissal.

(d) If the court makes a finding of abuse or neglect, it shall
determine, based upon the facts adduced during the fact-finding hearing
and any other additional facts presented to it, whether a preliminary
order pursuant to section one thousand twenty-seven is required to
protect the child's interests pending a final order of disposition. The
court shall state the grounds for its determination. In addition, a
child found to be abused or neglected may be removed and remanded to a
place approved for such purpose by the local social services department
or be placed in the custody of a suitable person, pending a final order
of disposition, if the court finds that there is a substantial
probability that the final order of disposition will be an order of
placement under section one thousand fifty-five. In determining whether
substantial probability exists, the court shall consider the
requirements of subdivision (b) of section one thousand fifty-two.

(e) If the court makes a finding of abuse, it shall specify the
paragraph or paragraphs of subdivision (e) of section one thousand
twelve of this act which it finds have been established. If the court
makes a finding of abuse as defined in paragraph (iii) of subdivision
(e) of section one thousand twelve of this act, it shall make a further
finding of the specific sex offense as defined in article one hundred
thirty of the penal law. In addition to a finding of abuse, the court
may enter a finding of severe abuse or repeated abuse, as defined in
subparagraphs (i), (ii) and (iii) of paragraph (a) or subparagraphs (i)
and (ii) of paragraph (b) of subdivision eight of section three hundred
eighty-four-b of the social services law, which shall be admissible in a
proceeding to terminate parental rights pursuant to paragraph (e) of
subdivision four of section three hundred eighty-four-b of the social
services law; provided, however, that a finding of severe or repeated
abuse under this section may be made against any respondent as defined
in subdivision (a) of section one thousand twelve of this act. If the
court makes such additional finding of severe abuse or repeated abuse,
the court shall state the grounds for its determination, which shall be
based upon clear and convincing evidence.

(f) Prior to accepting an admission to an allegation or permitting a
respondent to consent to a finding of neglect or abuse, the court shall
inform the respondent that such an admission or consent will result in
the court making a fact-finding order of neglect or abuse, as the case
may be, and shall further inform the respondent in substantially the
following terms of the potential consequences of such order, including
but not limited to the following:

(i) that the court will have the power to make an order of
disposition, which may include an order placing the subject child or
children in foster care until completion of the initial permanency
hearing scheduled pursuant to section one thousand eighty-nine of this
act and subject to successive extensions of placement at any subsequent
permanency hearings;

(ii) that the placement of the children in foster care may, if the
parent fails to maintain contact with or plan for the future of the
child, lead to proceedings for the termination of parental rights and to
the possibility of adoption of the child if the child remains in foster
care for fifteen of the most recent twenty-two months, the agency may be
required by law to file a petition to terminate parental rights;

(iii) that any report made to the state central register of child
abuse and maltreatment of allegations on which the court makes a finding
of abuse or neglect will remain indicated in the register until ten
years after the eighteenth birthday of the youngest child named in such
report unless such finding is vacated or dismissed, and that:

(A) the respondent will be unable to amend such report in the state
central register; and

(B) the existence of such report may be made known to employers
required to screen employee or volunteer applicants for positions where
the individual has the potential for regular and substantial contact
with children, and to child care agencies if the respondent applies to
become a foster parent or adoptive parent unless:

(1) the court finding is for neglect and the report is eight or more
years old; or

(2) the report was determined not to be relevant to positions
involving contact with children in an earlier administrative proceeding.

Any finding upon such an admission or consent made without such notice
being given by the court shall be vacated upon motion of any party. In
no event shall a person other than the respondent, either in person or
in writing, make an admission or consent to a finding of neglect or
abuse.

FCT 1051 2025-03-21

Sections:

Article 10 - Child Protective Proceedings
Part 1 - (1011 - 1018) Jurisdiction
1011 - Purpose.
1012 - Definitions.
1013 - Jurisdiction.
1014 - Transfer to and from family court; concurrent proceedings.
1015 - Venue.
1015-A - Court-ordered services.
1016 - Appointment of attorney for the child.
1017 - Placement of children.
1018 - Conferencing and mediation.
Part 2 - (1021 - 1030) Temporary Removal And Preliminary Orders
1021 - Temporary removal with consent.
1022 - Preliminary orders of court before petition filed.
1022-A - Preliminary orders; notice and appointment of counsel.
1023 - Procedure for issuance of temporary order.
1024 - Emergency removal without court order.
1026 - Action by the appropriate person designated by the court and child protective agency upon emergency removal.
1027 - Hearing and preliminary orders after filing of petition.
1027-A - Placement of siblings.
1028 - Application to return child temporarily removed.
1028-A - Application of a relative to become a foster parent.
1029 - Temporary order of protection.
1030 - Order of visitation by a respondent.
Part 3 - (1031 - 1040) Preliminary Procedure
1031 - Originating proceeding to determine abuse or neglect.
1032 - Persons who may originate proceedings.
1033 - Access to the court for the purpose of filing a petition.
1033-A - Initial appearance.
1033-B - Initial appearance; procedures.
1034 - Power to order investigations.
1035 - Issuance of summons; notice to certain interested persons and intervention.
1036 - Service of summons.
1037 - Issuance of warrant and reports to court.
1038 - Records and discovery involving abuse and neglect.
1038-A - Discovery; upon court order.
1039 - Adjournment in contemplation of dismissal.
1039-A - Procedures following adjournment in contemplation of dismissal.
1039-B - Termination of reasonable efforts.
1040 - Notice and right to be heard.
Part 4 - (1041 - 1049) Hearings
1041 - Required findings concerning notice.
1042 - Effect of absence of parent or other person responsible for care.
1043 - Hearings not open to the public.
1044 - Definition of "fact-finding hearing".
1045 - Definition of "dispositional hearing".
1046 - Evidence.
1047 - Sequence of hearings.
1048 - Adjournments.
1049 - Special consideration in certain cases.
Part 5 - (1051 - 1059) Orders
1051 - Sustaining or dismissing petition.
1052 - Disposition on adjudication.
1052-A - Post-dispositional procedures.
1052-B - Duties of counsel.
1052-C - Duty to report investigations to locate non-respondent parents or relatives.
1053 - Suspended judgment.
1054 - Release to custody of parent or other person responsible for care; supervision or order of protection.
1055 - Placement.
1055-A - Substantial failure of a material condition of surrender; enforcement of a contact agreement.
1055-B - Custody or guardianship with relatives or suitable persons pursuant to article six of this act or guardianship with such a person pursuant to article
1056 - Order of protection.
1056-A - Firearms; surrender and license suspension, revocation and ineligibility.
1057 - Supervision.
1058 - Expiration of orders.
Part 6 - (1061 - 1069) New Hearing And Reconsideration Of Orders
1061 - Staying, modifying, setting aside or vacating order.
1062 - Motion to terminate placement.
1063 - Service of motion; answer.
1064 - Examination of motion and answers; hearing.
1065 - Orders on hearing.
1066 - Successive motions.
1067 - Discontinuation of treatment by agency or institution.
1068 - Action on return from agency or institution.
1069 - Rules of court.
Part 7 - (1071 - 1075) Compliance With Orders
1071 - Failure to comply with terms and conditions of suspended judgment.
1072 - Failure to comply with terms and conditions of supervision.
1073 - Effect of running away from place of placement.
1074 - Release from responsibility under order of placement.
1075 - Special duties of attorney for the child.
Part 8 - (1081 - 1085) Visitation Of Minors In Foster Care
1081 - Visitation rights.
1082 - Approval, modification or denial of visitation rights.
1083 - Duration of orders affecting visitation rights.
1084 - Out-of-wedlock children; paternity.
1085 - Visitation and custody rights unenforceable; murder of parent, custodian, guardian, or child.

Search Decisions Citing Statute